Ons was daar – maar nie by Cuito nie.

[Toespraak van generaal-majoor Marius (Mo) Oelschig, SAW (afg.) tydens die bekendstelling van die boek Ons was daar, saamgestel deur generaal Jannie Geldenhuys, uitgegee deur Kraal Uitgewers.]

Generaal Jannie Geldenhuys voor 'n groot kaart wat die Kubaanse, Russiese en Suid-Afrikaanse ontmoeting in Angola aandui.

General Geldenhuys has asked me to say a few words about Operations Moduler, Hooper and Packer. These operations constituted the decisive armed clashes between the forces of Savimbi’s UNITA movement, supported by elements of the SA Defence Force, and those of the Angolan and Cuban Armed Forces, supported by Soviet military advisors and massive, unprecedented Soviet logistic support. The operations took place exclusively in the south-east of Angola and spanned the period June 1986 to August 1988.

There are a number of books dealing specifically with this phase of the war in Angola. Recommended reading are the books The War for Africa by Fred Bridgland, South Africa’s Border War by Willem Steenkamp and War in Angola – The Final South African Phase by Helmoed-Römer Heitman.  The latter provides a detailed tactical explanation of all the battles that took place.  I will in no way attempt to here summarise this excellent piece of contemporary military research.  What I do want to say is that an entire section of General Geldenhuys’ new book, twenty-seven chapters in all, is dedicated to Operations Moduler, Hooper and Packer. These are not one-eyed, sensation-seeking articles by newspaper hacks nor are they political spin by party-political propagandists; they are the personal stories of the men who were there.

You may now wish to ask why so much emphasis is being placed on just these operations when there were dozens more that took place elsewhere in Angola and SWA/Namibia at the same time. Allow me to explain.

At the time of Gen Magnus Malan’s death in July of this year the Sunday Times journalist Chris Barron wrote a biased, vituperative and totally unacceptable so-called obituary that appeared in the newspaper on 24 July. Besides being in very poor taste it is also exceptionally poor journalism, reflecting the on-going decline of a once-great South African newspaper.  Furthermore the article slanders several generations of patriotic South African servicemen and women, without whose sterling service and dedication to duty this country would be nothing more than just another failed African State.  Such slander cannot go unanswered and the soldiers’ stories in this book prove the lie of Barron’s message. Unfortunately his bias and vitriol provides grist to the mill of the ever-active anti-SA Defence Force lobby that continues unabated with its dissemination of Soviet-style propaganda and lies in an attempt to distort or to re-write the history, particularly the military history, of this country. Allow me to quote a single example.

Writing for The Independent as recently as 20 July 2011 the journalist Gavin Evans wrote that South Africa’s military support for UNITA “……. came to an end in 1988 when the SADF failed to take the town of Cuito Cuanavale in Angola, which prompted their retreat and a series of setbacks at the hands of the Cubans….”

This, and similar slanted and hopelessly inaccurate commentary, is nothing but an echo of the message put about internationally by, amongst others, the Cuban propaganda machine. To what purpose, you ask? Quite simply to justify the loss of thousands upon thousands of Cuban soldiers in far-off Angola; sacrificial cannon-fodder in pursuit of that failed ideology of communist global domination. Then, the old dictator Fidel Castro also needs to leave a legacy similar to that of the other revolutionary icon, yet hopelessly inadequate, Ché Guevara – and “Hero of the Battle of Cuito Cuanavale” appears to be the peg upon which he hopes to hang his rather shabby reputation. Yet, like so much else regarding the chimera of el Paraiso Cubano, there never was a Battle of Cuito Cuanavale.

The contribution to this book by the late Brig-Gen Junior Botha is particularly relevant. He was a senior staff officer at the Directorate of Operations at Army HQ at the time. He was consequently personally aware of every single directive, order and other operational correspondence between the Higher (Army) HQ and all subordinate HQs. He was fully aware of the strategy, plans and intentions of commanders in Pretoria and on the front. His detailed explanations make mince-meat of the arguments and opinions of the armchair critics, providing valuable insight into the level of strategic thought behind these operations. His conclusion is blunt and to the point – there never was a Battle of Cuito Cuanavale.

The myth of such a battle is, unfortunately, supported by the ruling party in our country for its own political purposes. Having come to power in South Africa it suits them to create the impression that the SADF was “defeated” in Angola. And this is not without precedent for, as the author Charles Frazier says in his book Thirteen Moons dealing with the dispossession and forced removal of the Cherokees in America, “…… it’s generally the victors who get to make up the stories and furthermore that they have a great deal of leeway in regard to adherence to facts and especially interpretation and opinions, not to mention outright lies.” All we can do is pen our recollections and tell our stories in the hope that the generations of children to come, and possibly the odd serious researcher or military historian, will read them, consider them and embrace them.    Read the book and learn the truth from the men that were there.

So, in conclusion, allow me to summarise the basic facts regarding Operations Moduler, Hooper and Packer.

  • In 1986 five FAPLA conventional brigades launched an offensive against Mavinga and Jamba in south-eastern Angola. Their aim was the military destruction of UNITA.
  • The SA Defence force deployed a limited number of conventional forces in support of UNITA.  Their aim was to prevent the capture of Mavinga and to drive the FAPLA forces back to Cuito Cuanavale from whence they had come.

Only politicians, denialists and propagandists could ever manufacture a Cuban victory from the embarrassing disaster that ensued.  The result was an epic, resounding military victory for the South African forces that participated in this historic campaign. Nothing can ever deny them that honour.  Read about it in this book!

"Ons was daar" - saamgestel deur generaal Jannie Geldenhuys (Kraal Uitgewers).

My final words are directed at all the men and women of the South African Armed Forces, past and present. Whilst we should forever honour our own heroes let us also honour our foes, especially the fallen, and respect them all in the spirit of the universal Brotherhood of Warriors. Let us take pride in our military achievements and not allow anyone to deny or to vitiate our glorious military heritage. We should rather build upon the sterling example of those that went before us.  And before we ever question the manner in which the SADF persecuted the Border War we should take serious heed of the following advice taken from the historical novel Excalibur by Bernard Cornwell (page 192):

Only a fool wants war, but once a war starts then it cannot be fought half-heartedly.  It cannot even be fought with regret, but must be waged with a savage joy in defeating the enemy. A man should love peace, but if he cannot fight with all his heart then he will not have peace.

Thank you all, and enjoy the book.

[Om die boek te bestel teen R300 (posgeld uitgesluit), SMS die woord ‘GRENS’ na 34388.]

Hierdie plasing is deur ʼn onafhanklike persoon of onderneming saamgestel. Die menings en standpunte wat in hierdie skrywe uitgespreek word, is nie noodwendig die beleid of standpunt van Maroela Media se redakteurs, direksie of aandeelhouers nie. –Red

Deel van: Meningsvormers

ondersteun maroela media só

Sonder Maroela Media sou jy nie geweet het nie. Help om jou gebalanseerde en betroubare nuusbron se toekoms te verseker. Maak nou ʼn vrywillige bydrae. Onthou – ons nuus bly gratis.

Maak 'n bydrae

Nou pra' jý

6 Kommentare

Louis du Plessis ·

Mo ~

1 Jy slaan die spyker op sy kop! Diegene wat nie grensdiens verrig het, maar verkies het om agter mammies se rokbande weg te kruip en van daar af venynige opmerkings te maak, moet eerder stilbly. Hierdie bundel maak elke soldaat weer opnuut trots op die professionaliteit van die destydse Suid-Afrkaanse Weermag.

2 Dankie vir jou skerp insig! Voorspoed!

Lynn Kruger ·

Ek het die voorreg gehad om die boekvrystelling in Capital Park by te woon. Dit was nie net terugblink op my kinderdae in Oshakati nie maar ook ‘n insiggewende oggend met die regte feite en ‘n vars perspektief om die waarheid. Dankie Moira-Marie en Genl Oelschig vir die besonderse oggend. Ek het die boek aan my pa, Brig Genl Clive Giles gegee en dit is wonderlik om sy reaksies te sien en hoor wanneer hy die boek lees.

Then you will know the truth and the truth shall set you free – John 8:32

Christo Potgieter ·

Ek het so pas generaal Jannie Geldhuys se boek “Ons was Daar” klaar gelees. Wat ‘n meesterstuk van feite. Enige persoon wat deelgeneem het aan die SAW operasies MOET hierdie boek lees. Hierdie boek stel feite soos geen ander wat ek gelees het nie. Die skrywer weerspiël die professionaliteit en kwaliteit van opperbevelvoerders wat die SAW gedien tot en met 1994. Feitelik, tot die punt met genoegsame verwysings en navorsing wat nie betwis kan word nie.
Generaal ek salueer u.

Erika (Biene) Ottermann ·

Generaal Geldenhyus, graag wil ek u bedank vir u moeite om so `n fantastiese boek saam te stel. Ek is nou al vir maande besig om in ‘Ons was daar’ te lees, want die inligting is intensief en emosioneel (in die beste bedoeling van die woord) en dit vat tyd om dit te verwerk. Van my vriende is verbaas, dat ek as 75jarige vrou die boek lees, maar ek beveel almal aan om dit te doen en om die waarheid van ons geskiedenis te ervaar.

George Pelser ·


Baie dankie dat u die feite stel want ek is nes die paar duisend manne wat daar was,(met alle respek)goed gatvol vir die snert en leuens wat vir die publiek deur die vyandige linkses gevoer word aangaande die gebeure.

Die feit is dat hulle hul hand oorspeel het en die SAW erg onderskat het en op hul maai gekry het.Ek was ook daar en dit was ‘n groot voorreg om in hierdie puik weermag en onder ‘n Generaal soos u te dien.

Ek salueer u!

Johan ·

Ek was ook daar.Ek was trots om deel te wees.Die fotos spreek boek dele wat ek het en die trots
in die mense se oe was groot om dit te doen vir ons Suid Afrika, en nou.
Generaal Jannie Geldenhuys het in Angola gese hy verdeedig ons land se klein grense hier,as daai grense weg gevat word ,sal ons nie al die grense meer kan verdeedig word nie.
En kyk nou!

O wee, die gesang is uit! Kommentaar word ná 48 uur op ʼn artikel op Maroela Media gesluit. Kom kuier gerus verder op ʼn meer onlangse artikel.